Skip to content
CuisineDish type

Arroz con Menestra y Carne Asada

A Guayaquil-associated coastal plate of fluffy white rice, thick canary bean menestra, char-grilled beef and crisp green-plantain patacones.

Ecuadorian plate of white rice, dark canary bean menestra, grilled beef, golden patacones and avocadoArroz con menestra y carne asada
Sharing is available after a live page URL is set.
4 servingsservings
30mpreparation
2h 10mcooking
Moderatedifficulty

A Guayaquil favourite from the Ecuadorian coast

White rice, thick canary bean stew, grilled beef and crisp green-plantain patacones make a generous coastal plate.

Arroz con menestra y carne asada brings three comforting components together: a mound of separate white rice grains, a thick seasoned bean stew and beef cooked over a hot grill. In Guayaquil, it is commonly rounded out with crisp patacones, fried twice from green plantain. Each part has its own texture, yet the rice catches the savoury bean sauce and the charred beef makes the meal substantial. This home version serves four and stages the bean cooking, refrito, rice, grilling and plantain so the components reach the table hot.

The meal is strongly associated with Guayaquil and the Ecuadorian coast. El Universo described it as a familiar household dish that later became a restaurant staple, and called the plate with grilled beef and patacón a signature of Guayaquil food culture. University and culinary references also document the named combination. The evidence supports a popular regional dish with wide recognition; it does not establish an official national-dish designation. The roster therefore keeps Guayaquil as its important regional context without presenting the recipe as a formally declared national emblem.

“Menestra” refers here to a thick, seasoned preparation of legumes served with rice, rather than a thin soup. Regional recipes vary: some use lentils, while the Guayaquil canary-bean version is especially well documented. This recipe follows the latter. Dried beans are soaked overnight, drained, then simmered in fresh water until creamy and fully tender. The overnight soak is passive and is not included in the listed 160 minutes of active preparation and cooking. Older beans can take longer, so tenderness matters more than the clock.

The refrito builds the stew’s flavour from red onion, green pepper, tomato, garlic, cumin, oregano and achiote oil. Softening the vegetables first lets their sweetness and savoury notes develop before they meet the beans. A little finely grated green plantain is stirred in near the end in one documented coastal approach; it thickens the cooking liquid without needing flour. Add it gradually and give it several minutes to cook. The finished menestra should be spoonable and cohesive, with whole beans still visible rather than mashed into a paste.

Cook rice separately so the grains stay distinct. Rinse it to remove loose surface starch, then cook it covered with measured water and let it rest before fluffing. The beef is simply seasoned with garlic, cumin, salt and pepper, then seared on a barbecue or hot grill pan. Use a clean food thermometer: whole beef steaks should reach 63 °C (145 °F) and rest for at least 3 minutes. Insert the probe from the side into the center of a thinner steak for a reliable reading.

Patacones contribute a crisp, savoury contrast. Green plantain rounds are fried once until tender, pressed flat, then fried a second time until golden. Work in small batches so the oil temperature remains steady, and drain them on a rack or paper towel. If deep-frying is inconvenient, pan-fry in a shallow layer of oil, turning carefully; the rounds may be less evenly crisp. Ripe fried plantain is another documented accompaniment, but this version uses green plantain for patacones.

Serve the components side by side rather than mixing the rice and stew in the pot. A spoonful of menestra can be poured over part of the rice, while patacones and slices of beef remain easy to pick up. Avocado, a simple tomato salad, lime and ají are optional accompaniments; households and eateries vary in what they add. Keep the beans moist but thick, and slice the rested beef across the grain if the cut has long fibres. The plate is hearty without needing additional garnish.

Food safety is part of the method. Soak beans in the refrigerator, discard the soaking water and cook them in fresh water until fully tender. Keep raw beef and its utensils apart from cooked rice and other ready-to-eat food; wash hands, board and tools after handling it. Refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours in shallow containers, use them within 3–4 days and reheat to 74 °C (165 °F). The finished dish is a popular coastal and Guayaquil-associated Ecuadorian meal, with household variation in the legume, meat cut and sides.

Ingredients at a glance

Recipe card

Arroz con Menestra y Carne Asada

servings4 servings
preparation: 30 mincooking: 130 mintotal time: 2 hr 40 min

Menestra

Menestra and rice

Rice

Grilled beef

Refrito

Refrito and beef

Patacones

Seasoning

To serve

To serve

Equipment

Method

80 min

Soak and cook the beans

The night before, sort and rinse the beans, cover with plenty of cold water and refrigerate to soak. Drain and discard the soaking water. Place the beans in a large pot, cover with fresh water by 5 cm, bring to a boil, then reduce to a steady simmer. Cook until creamy inside and fully tender, usually 60–80 minutes depending on age. Add hot water if needed to keep them covered. Do not add tomato or other acidic ingredients until the beans are tender. Reserve the beans in their cooking liquid.

25 min

Make and finish the menestra

Heat the achiote oil in a skillet or pot over medium heat. Add the red onion and green pepper and cook until soft, about 6 minutes. Stir in the garlic, tomato, cumin, oregano, salt and pepper; cook until the tomato collapses into a fragrant refrito. Add the cooked beans with enough reserved liquid to make a thick stew. Simmer gently for 10 minutes. Stir in the finely grated half plantain and cook 5–8 minutes more until it thickens the sauce without turning pasty. Fold in chopped cilantro and taste for seasoning.

20 min

Cook the rice and prepare the beef

While the menestra simmers, rinse and drain the rice. Put it in a saucepan with 500 ml fresh water and about one-third of the salt. Bring to a boil, cover, lower the heat and cook until the water is absorbed and the grains are tender, about 15 minutes. Remove from the heat and rest covered for 5 minutes, then fluff. Pat the beef dry. Season both sides with the remaining salt, pepper, cumin and half the minced garlic. Keep raw beef and its utensils separate from ready-to-eat foods; wash hands and surfaces after handling.

20 min

Grill the beef

Heat a barbecue or grill pan until very hot and lightly oil the cooking surface. Grill the steaks in batches without crowding, turning once when browned. Time depends on thickness and preferred doneness. For a safe minimum, cook whole beef steaks to 63 °C (145 °F) and let them rest for at least 3 minutes; insert a clean thermometer from the side into the center of a thin steak. Transfer to a clean plate, rest, then slice across the grain if desired. Never return cooked meat to the raw-meat plate.

15 min

Fry patacones and serve

Heat 2–3 cm neutral oil in a deep skillet to about 170 °C (340 °F). Fry plantain rounds in batches for 3–4 minutes until just tender but pale. Drain, press each round to about 1 cm thick, then fry again until crisp and golden. Drain and season lightly. Serve hot rice, a generous spoonful of thick menestra, grilled beef and patacones together, with avocado, salad, lime and ají if desired. Refrigerate leftovers within 2 hours in shallow containers, use within 3–4 days, and reheat to 74 °C (165 °F).

Tips

01

Soak the beans safely

Soak dried beans in the refrigerator overnight and discard the soaking water before cooking.

02

Thicken the stew gradually

Add grated green plantain a little at a time; simmer until cooked through and stop while the beans remain distinct.

03

Keep rice grains separate

Rinse the rice, use measured water and let it rest covered before fluffing.

04

Use a clean thermometer

Check whole beef steaks at 63 °C (145 °F), then rest for at least 3 minutes.

05

Fry plantain in batches

Do not crowd the pan; stable oil temperature helps patacones crisp evenly.

Recipe variations

Use lentils for a quicker menestra

A well-documented Ecuadorian version uses lentils instead of beans. Lentils do not need overnight soaking; simmer until tender, then finish them with the same refrito and adjust the liquid.

Choose another bean or grill cut

Other beans and grilling cuts appear in household and regional versions. Cooking times vary; cook beans until fully tender and use a thermometer for the beef.

Serve ripe plantain instead

Some meals include ripe fried plantain rather than patacones. This changes the sweet-savoury balance but remains a serving variation, not a separate dish identity.

Common questions while cooking

ProblemWhat to do
The beans are still firm after the expected timeContinue simmering in fresh water until creamy; add tomato only after the beans are tender.
The menestra is too thinSimmer uncovered and stir in a little more grated green plantain; cook until the sauce coats a spoon.
The menestra is too thickStir in hot bean-cooking liquid or water a few tablespoons at a time.
The patacones are oily or softFry smaller batches and let the oil return to temperature between batches.

Substitutions

Original ingredientPractical substituteWhat changes
Dried canary beansDried brown or red beansThe flavour and cooking time will differ; soak and cook until tender. Lentils are another documented Ecuadorian menestra option and need no overnight soak.
Achiote oilNeutral oilThe stew will lack achiote’s red-gold colour; do not replace it with hot chilli oil.
Barbecue grillHeavy grill pan or cast-iron skilletPreheat well, ventilate the kitchen and cook in batches.

Storing and reheating

Cool rice and menestra promptly; store the cooked components separately for best texture.

Refrigerate

Refrigerate rice, menestra and beef within 2 hours in shallow covered containers. Use within 3–4 days.

Freeze

Freeze cooled beans and beef in airtight portions. Rice can also be frozen, though its texture may soften slightly.

Reheat safely

Reheat leftovers until the center reaches 74 °C (165 °F). Add a splash of water to rice or menestra and stir during reheating.

Frequently asked questions

Is arroz con menestra y carne asada Ecuador’s official national dish?

It is a popular Ecuadorian coastal dish strongly associated with Guayaquil. The sources reviewed do not establish an official national-dish designation.

Which beans should I use for menestra?

This version uses dried canary beans, a well-documented Guayaquil style. Lentils and other beans also appear in Ecuadorian menestra recipes.

Can I make the menestra without an overnight soak?

Use a pressure cooker according to its manual, or choose lentils for a no-soak variation. Do not shorten cooking until the beans are fully tender.

What temperature should the beef reach?

For whole beef steaks, use a thermometer to reach at least 63 °C (145 °F), followed by a 3-minute rest. Insert the probe from the side into a thin steak.

Can I prepare the components ahead?

Yes. Cool cooked rice and beans promptly in shallow containers and refrigerate. Reheat thoroughly to 74 °C (165 °F); grill the beef and fry patacones close to serving.

What are patacones?

They are green plantain rounds fried once, pressed flat and fried again until crisp. They are also called tostones in some countries.