Arnhemse meisjes are small, crisp biscuits associated with Arnhem in Gelderland. Their name is Dutch for “Arnhem girls,” but the food is a thin oval cookie, not a filled pastry. A regional heritage account connects their baking in Arnhem with baker Hagdorn in 1829 and describes a yeast-and-butter dough rolled in coarse sugar. Because the baker’s formula was reportedly kept secret and published home versions differ, this recipe is described as a documented home adaptation rather than a guaranteed copy of the bakery original.
The dough is unusually rich for a small biscuit: a sticky yeast mixture is worked with pieces of butter, then left to rest overnight in the refrigerator. The long cold rest lets the dough firm up for shaping and gives the yeast time to work slowly. The heritage recipe uses fine wheat flour, milk, fresh yeast, lemon juice, butter and salt; the sugar quantity is not specified, so use coarse white sugar as needed to coat the dough during rolling and shaping.
Start by dissolving fresh yeast in milk that feels lukewarm, not hot. Mix the flour and salt, then add the yeast mixture and lemon juice. Beat in the butter a little at a time until no large pieces remain and the dough looks sticky and cohesive. It will not feel like a dry bread dough. Cover it and refrigerate overnight. The next day it should be firmer and easier to portion, though still soft enough to roll.
Shape the chilled dough into a log and cut it into small portions. Roll each portion into a ball, cover them, and let them rest for about an hour. This second rest relaxes the dough after cutting and gives the pieces time to soften slightly before rolling. Work with one ball at a time while keeping the others covered so their surfaces do not dry out.
Roll each ball through coarse sugar, then use a rolling pin to flatten it into the long oval described in the regional account, about 15 cm long and 5–6 cm wide. Press sugar into both sides as you roll. The ovals should be thin and evenly shaped so they bake at the same pace. Leave space between them on the lined trays; the biscuits spread slightly and the sugar melts around their edges.
Bake at 165 °C for about 25 minutes, until the biscuits are dry, crisping and lightly golden. The source advises not letting them become too dark. Sugar can darken quickly near the edges, so check the first tray before the full bake time and adjust only within the stated doneness cue. Transfer the hot biscuits carefully to a wire rack and let them cool completely; they become crisper as they cool.
Serve the biscuits once fully cool, when the sugar coating is crisp and the centre has a delicate snap. They are suited to a coffee or tea break and can also be crumbled over a dessert, a use noted in regional food writing. Keep the baked biscuits in a dry, airtight container after cooling to protect their crisp texture. This practical storage advice is editorial handling guidance, not a claim about historic practice.
Allow enough time for both rests when planning the bake: the first is overnight in the refrigerator and the second lasts about an hour after portioning. The total time shown is an estimate that includes those rests, while the preparation figure is hands-on work. Depending on tray size and oven behavior, the batch may need more than one round of baking. Keep later shaped ovals cool while the first tray bakes, and use the same spacing and thickness throughout for more even browning.