Skip to content
Dutch cookingSnacks

Dutch New Herring with Onion and Pickles (Hollandse Nieuwe)

Serve Hollandse Nieuwe at home with finely chopped onion and crisp pickled gherkins, using chilled, ready-to-eat Dutch herring fillets.

A ready-to-eat herring fillet with onion and pickled gherkins on a Dutch-style serving plateDutch New Herring with Onion and Pickles (Hollandse Nieuwe)
4servings
15mpreparation
0mcooking
Moderatedifficulty

Dutch New Herring, Served Simply

A cold, ready-to-eat preparation of Hollandse Nieuwe with finely chopped onion and crisp pickled gherkins.

Hollandse Nieuwe is a familiar sight at Dutch fish counters when the new herring season begins. The name refers to a specific style of Dutch herring rather than to a cooked dish: the fish is prepared and sold ready to eat, then served without further heat. The European Union recognizes Hollandse Nieuwe as a Traditional Speciality Guaranteed, a designation connected to its traditional character and method. This recipe keeps the presentation close to the straightforward market serving: one herring fillet per person, with chopped onion and pickle alongside.

The word nieuwe is seasonal. The Dutch Visbureau describes the annual catch as beginning around the middle of May and continuing into July, while the official public season launch usually takes place around June. Voedingscentrum says the name Hollandse Nieuwe is used for herring caught and sold from May through September; after 30 September, the Dutch Visbureau says the product is called maatjesharing. Availability therefore depends on the season and on how the fishmonger labels the product. For this recipe, buy fillets specifically sold as ready-to-eat Hollandse Nieuwe or ask the fishmonger which equivalent is currently available.

The name also has a product standard behind it. Voedingscentrum states that herring must contain at least 16 percent fat to be sold as Hollandse Nieuwe. The fat gives the fish its characteristic soft, rich texture, while salting and maturation distinguish it from a plain fresh herring fillet. These details describe the product; they are not steps for preparing it at home. The recipe deliberately begins with finished, commercially prepared fillets, since reproducing the curing and parasite-control process in a home kitchen would require additional validated controls that a short serving recipe cannot provide.

At a Dutch fish stall, herring is often served with finely chopped raw onion and something pickled. Fish sellers commonly offer those accompaniments separately so the eater can choose how much to add. Their sharp, fresh flavours cut through the fish’s richness, but they remain supporting elements rather than a sauce that covers the herring. This version uses a small onion and sliced gherkins, both easy to prepare while the fish stays refrigerated. The amounts are a practical starting point for four portions; the onion can be served at the table so each person can add as much as they like.

There is no cooking stage here. That is important both to the dish’s identity and to the way the recipe should be read: Hollandse Nieuwe is salted and matured herring served as a ready-to-eat product, not a raw fillet that should be cured or seasoned at home. Keep the package sealed and cold while chopping the accompaniments, open it only when the plates are ready, and serve the fish promptly. The recipe assumes cleaned, boneless or nearly boneless fillets from a fishmonger or retailer. Check each fillet for bones before serving, since fish sold as nearly boneless can still contain an occasional small bone.

Food safety still matters even when the fish is sold ready to eat. Voedingscentrum explains that fish intended to be eaten raw or almost raw in Europe must have been frozen first to control herringworm parasites. That control does not remove every food-safety risk. The same Dutch guidance advises pregnant people, young children, older adults and people with reduced immunity to avoid raw fish, including Hollandse Nieuwe. This serving is therefore not suitable for those groups unless the fish is thoroughly cooked in another dish; cooking would, however, change the character of this preparation.

For the best texture, take the herring out of the refrigerator only when the onion, gherkins and serving plates are ready. Finely chop the onion so it can be picked up easily with each bite, and cut the gherkins into neat slices rather than mixing them into the fish. Arrange the fillet whole or in a few large pieces, with the accompaniments close by. There is no need to add lemon, herbs or oil to this simple version: the fish’s own seasoning should remain clear.

Serve immediately as a small lunch or light meal. If you want to offer bread, treat it as a separate table choice rather than folding it into the fish preparation; the serving below is measured only for the herring and its two accompaniments. Keep the fish away from the chopped onion and pickle until plating if you want to store those components separately. Return any remaining herring to the refrigerator promptly, follow the package’s use-by date and storage directions, and do not leave perishable fish out for more than two hours. For an opened pack, Voedingscentrum lists one to two days refrigerated, but the product label should take precedence.

This recipe is intentionally short in technique but careful in scope. It records one recognizable way to present Hollandse Nieuwe without claiming that every Dutch household or fish stall serves it identically. Onion may be omitted by diners who prefer the fish plain, and the amount of pickle can be adjusted at the table, both are included here to make the four-portion serving clear. The result should be cool, softly textured herring with the onion and pickle offered as crisp, acidic counterpoints.

Ingredients

Recipe card

Dutch New Herring with Onion and Pickles (Hollandse Nieuwe)

servings4
preparation: 15 mincooking: 0 mintotal time: 15 min

Herring

Accompaniments

Equipment

Method

5 min

Chop the onion

Peel the onion and cut it into a fine, even dice. Transfer it to a small serving bowl and keep it covered in the refrigerator while you prepare the rest.

3 min

Slice the gherkins

Drain the gherkins and slice them into bite-size pieces. Cover and refrigerate them until the plates are ready.

2 min

Open and check the herring

Keep the herring chilled until the accompaniments and plates are ready. Check the package use-by date, then open it just before serving. Do not serve fish that has an unusual smell or dull appearance.

5 min

Arrange and serve

Place one herring fillet on each plate. Set out the chopped onion and sliced gherkins alongside so each person can add them to taste. Serve immediately and return any remaining fish to the refrigerator within two hours.

Tips for success

01

Keep the fish cold

Leave the package refrigerated until the onion, gherkins and plates are ready. Put perishable fish back in the refrigerator promptly and never leave it out for more than two hours.

02

Let diners add the onion

Serve the finely chopped onion in a small bowl so each person can choose how much to add.

Serving and storage

How should leftover herring be stored?

Follow the package instructions and use-by date. Keep opened herring covered in the refrigerator at 4 °C; Voedingscentrum lists one to two days for an opened product. Discard it if it has an unusual smell or dull appearance.

Frequently asked questions

Is Hollandse Nieuwe cooked?

No. It is commercially prepared, salted and matured herring served without cooking. This recipe is for ready-to-eat fillets; it is not a home-curing method.

What is Hollandse Nieuwe usually served with?

Dutch fish sellers commonly serve herring with finely chopped onion and pickles. Serving customs vary, so the accompaniments can be offered separately.

Can pregnant people or other vulnerable groups eat this recipe?

No. Dutch food-safety guidance advises pregnant people, young children, older adults and people with reduced immunity to avoid raw fish, including Hollandse Nieuwe.

How should leftover herring be stored?

Follow the package instructions and use-by date. Keep opened herring covered in the refrigerator at 4 °C; Voedingscentrum lists one to two days for an opened product. Discard it if it has an unusual smell or dull appearance.